Analysis · · Legal news · 3 min read
Drafting arbitration clauses in commercial contracts for validity

A vague arbitration clause can lead to prolonged jurisdiction disputes. This article analyses the key elements under the 2010 Law on Commercial Arbitration and common drafting errors.
Key points
- The agreement must show clear intent to arbitrate and identify the institution or form of arbitration.
- Avoid hybrid clauses and incorrect institution names.
Arbitration clauses are usually drafted on the last page of a contract and receive little attention until a dispute arises. An ambiguous clause can lead to prolonged argument over jurisdiction and may even see the arbitration agreement declared invalid. This article analyses the key elements under the 2010 Law on Commercial Arbitration.
Conditions for a valid arbitration agreement
Under the 2010 Law on Commercial Arbitration, an arbitration agreement may be made before or after a dispute arises, either as a clause in a contract or as a separate agreement. The dispute must fall within the scope that the law allows to be arbitrated, and the signatory must have authority.
The agreement must show the parties' intent to choose arbitration as the dispute resolution method and identify the arbitral institution or ad hoc arbitration. Agreements missing this are a common cause of disputes over validity.
Elements a clause should contain
- Scope of disputes: state "all disputes arising from or in connection with this contract", including interpretation, performance and termination.
- Arbitral institution: give its exact name; avoid referring to an institution that no longer exists or an inaccurate name.
- Number and appointment of arbitrators: one or three, and the appointment mechanism if the parties do not agree.
- Seat and language: these affect the procedural law and cost.
- Governing law of the contract: choose the substantive law clearly.
Common drafting errors
Hybrid clauses
Allowing one party to choose arbitration or court at will can cause disputes over validity and has led to lengthy jurisdiction fights. Choose a single mechanism.
Inaccurate institution names
Wrong or generic references to an arbitration centre make it hard to determine jurisdiction.
Overlooking the negotiation step
Many contracts provide for negotiation or mediation before arbitration. Without clear timelines and methods, this step can be abused to delay.
Arbitration or court
The choice depends on the transaction. Arbitration is often preferred when confidentiality, arbitrators with industry expertise and cross-border enforceability matter. Courts may suit better where an appeal mechanism is needed or where the counterparty is likely to be uncooperative in arbitration.
Conclusion
Spending time on the dispute clause during negotiation is usually far cheaper than dealing with the consequences of a flawed one. We recommend companies review their standard contract templates at least every two years.




