Dinh Gia & PartnersLaw Office

Legal update · · Legal news · 3 min read

Dismissal procedure under the 2019 Labour Code

Most dismissal cases lost by employers turn on procedural errors. This article summarises the disciplinary process, common mistakes and the consequences of getting it wrong.

Key points

  1. The employer must prove the employee's fault.
  2. Missing limitation periods or the wrong attendees can make a decision unlawful.
  3. Distinguish disciplinary dismissal from unilateral termination.

Employee discipline, and dismissal in particular, is among the most common sources of labour disputes. In most cases employers lose not because the employee committed no violation, but because the employer did not follow the correct procedure under the 2019 Labour Code.

Foundational principles

Under the 2019 Labour Code the employer bears the burden of proving the employee's fault when imposing discipline. Forms of discipline must be set out in work rules registered as required, and the process must observe the statutory time limits and procedure.

This means incomplete or invalidly issued work rules can void an entire disciplinary decision, even where the misconduct is real.

Recommended disciplinary process

  • Gather evidence: incident reports, documents, system data and witness statements, all properly kept.
  • Notify the disciplinary meeting: written notice to the employee, the grassroots employee representative organisation (if any) and, where necessary, the employee's legal representative, ahead of the meeting within the statutory period.
  • Hold the meeting: the employee may defend themselves or be assisted by a lawyer or representative organisation; minutes must be taken.
  • Issue the decision: in writing, within the limitation period, stating the grounds and form of discipline.

Frequent errors

Missing the limitation period

There are limits on the time to impose discipline. Employers must pinpoint when the misconduct was discovered and track the deadline.

Wrong attendees

If the workplace has an employee representative organisation that was not invited, or valid notice cannot be proven, the decision may be declared unlawful.

Confusing discipline with unilateral termination

Dismissal is a form of discipline, distinct from unilateral termination because an employee habitually fails to perform. The two grounds have different procedures and conditions, and the employer must choose the right one from the outset.

Consequences of getting it wrong

If a court finds a dismissal unlawful, the employer may have to reinstate the employee, pay wages for the period out of work, pay social insurance contributions and pay compensation as provided by law. These costs are usually far greater than the cost of getting the process right the first time.

Recommendations

  • Review work rules at least annually and check them against actual practice.
  • Train line managers to record violations and preserve evidence.
  • Consult counsel before dismissing anyone in a key role.
Note: the above is general in nature. Each case has its own facts and needs specific assessment.

Labour Disputes